top of page

Fiduciary Compliance Update, November 2026: A Final PBM Rule, a Suit Against UnitedHealth, and Three Dates

Nov 2
9 min read

October delivered the rule that September did not. On October 29 the Labor Department released its final rule on PBM fee disclosure for large self-insured health plans. In the same month, six large employers sued UnitedHealth Group in federal court in Texas, and the dates for two federal systems firmed up. This is the digest of the November issue of The Fiduciary Briefing. Every item below is also logged in the Litigation and Regulatory Tracker.

The Labor Department finalizes its PBM fee disclosure rule

The rule carries the identifier RIN 1210-AB37 and amends 29 CFR Part 2550. It requires pharmacy benefit managers, and brokerage and consulting providers affiliated with them, to disclose their compensation to the fiduciaries of large self-insured group health plans, so those fiduciaries can make the reasonableness determination that ERISA Section 408(b)(2) requires. The Department says the rule also includes provisions that let fiduciaries verify what is disclosed.

It covers plans of employers with at least 100 employees and plans with at least 100 participants. The Federal Register version, published November 2, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 69092), says in its DATES section that the rule is effective January 4, 2027 and applies to plan years beginning on or after July 1, 2027. Disclosures come at contracting, extension, or renewal and then every six months, or quarterly if the plan asks. The Department's preamble describes items such as spread compensation and drug pricing methodology. Press coverage reports the Department's projections of $22 billion in lower drug costs over ten years and first-year PBM compliance costs of about $1 million. Those are agency projections, not realized figures. The Pharmaceutical Care Management Association called the rule "a solution in search of a problem." The separate CAA 2026 provisions apply to plan years beginning on or after August 3, 2028. The rule's preamble also notes an earlier CAA 2026 amendment: effective February 3, 2026, ERISA's compensation disclosure requirement (Section 408(b)(2)(B)) extends to a broad range of service providers to group health plans, including third party administrators. Those providers must already make the statute's general compensation disclosures to rely on the exemption, and the rule implements that requirement in detail for PBMs and their affiliated brokers and consultants.

What to do: Add disclosure and verification rights to your PBM and consultant contracts at the next opportunity, name who on the committee will review the first disclosures, and have counsel read the Federal Register version. Ask your TPA in writing for the compensation disclosure the statute now requires of it. When the first disclosures arrive, compare them to what your contracts actually allow. A disclosure only protects the plan if someone reads it against the agreement. Contracts you sign this winter may still be in force when the first disclosures come due. Our full walk-through of the rule covers the dates and what is still open, and the PBM conflict checklist gives you the questions to ask.

Six large sponsors sue UnitedHealth Group over claims payment

Aramark, Kraft Heinz, Whirlpool, W.W. Grainger, Ralph Lauren, and Sterling Jewelers, with their benefit committees and plans, sued UnitedHealth Group and five affiliated entities on October 20 in the Eastern District of Texas (Aramark Services Inc. et al. v. United Health Group Inc. et al., No. 2:26-cv-00949). The suit invokes ERISA's civil enforcement provision. The docket lists the complaint as filed under seal and also carries a redacted 62-page version (Doc. 3), which we read. The redacted complaint alleges that UnitedHealth, as administrator of the plans, breached its ERISA fiduciary duties and engaged in prohibited transactions through improper claim payments, cross-plan offsetting, undisclosed fees, commingling of plan assets, and limits on audit rights and access to claims data. The plaintiffs ask the court for, among other relief, a preliminary injunction requiring UnitedHealth to provide claims data for the plans. UnitedHealthcare told the press that it strongly disagrees with the allegations and intends to vigorously defend against them. Those allegations are untested. The docket, last updated October 30 in the records we could read, showed no response from UnitedHealth.

It is Aramark's third suit against a claims administrator. The en banc Fifth Circuit has not ruled in Aramark v. Aetna. In Aramark v. QCC, the defendants answered with counterclaims on October 9, and Aramark moved to dismiss them on October 23.

What to do: Ask your administrator in writing how it would handle a request for claim-level data and a review of how your plan's claims were paid, and what your contract says about offsets across plans. Put the answer in the committee record. The complaint puts how claims were paid, and the plans' access to claims data, at issue. If no one outside your administrator reviews your plan's claims, before or after payment, your committee has no record that it looked. For a related look at who decides which claims get checked, see Self-Funded Employers Pay Like Medicare. They Just Don't Check Like Medicare.

Three more filings worth a look

Kreutzmann v. Cigna (S.D. Cal., No. 3:26-cv-05836, filed October 12) alleges that Cigna, as administrator of a self-funded plan, uses a shared-savings arrangement that suppresses reimbursement of out-of-network ground ambulance claims. The complaint alleges that Cigna's administrative services agreements entitle it to charge the employer a cost containment fee of up to 29% of the difference between a ground ambulance provider's billed charge and the lower amount the plan pays, and that in the plaintiff's case Cigna charged his employer 29% of a $3,258.14 reduction, nearly $1,000. It is the third administrator shared-savings theory on our tracker, after Wesco v. BCBSM and Tiara Yachts v. BCBSM.

If you buy voluntary benefits or advise those who do, two other filings deserve a read. Erickson v. Lockton and Daniel v. Aon each allege that a benefits broker acted as a fiduciary of its own employee plan while setting the commissions built into participant-paid premiums.

All three are allegations. When we read the dockets, which can run a few days behind the court, none showed an answer from any defendant.

What to do: If your TPA or carrier earns a fee tied to savings, ask in writing how the fee is calculated, whether it applies to claim types where balance billing can follow, and what your committee reviewed before agreeing to it. Then ask whether the fee rewards the administrator for correcting its own errors, the theory behind Wesco and Tiara Yachts. Put the answer in the record.

Three dates to put on your calendar before the end of the year

CMS says that from November 1 the Federal IDR Gateway initiation form enforces a 50-line-item cap on batched disputes and a 30-business-day cooling-off period for batched disputes whose open negotiation period begins on or after that date. The web forms for starting, responding to, and selecting an entity for a No Surprises Act dispute go live on November 13. Web forms outside the Gateway stop being available after January 15, 2027, except the resubmission form.

Separately, the Transparency in Coverage final rule published October 6 (91 Fed. Reg. 63748) takes effect December 7. It moves in-network reporting to the provider-network level, lowers the claims threshold for out-of-network files from 20 to 11, moves updates of the in-network rate and out-of-network files from monthly to quarterly, adds taxonomy and utilization files, and requires an attestation that the files are accurate. According to the Departments' FAQs, the amended file requirements apply from March 6, 2027, and the new files from September 6, 2027.

What to do: If your plan runs disputes itself, confirm your Gateway account is ready before November 13. If a TPA handles them, get written confirmation of who is responsible. Ask whoever produces your price transparency files how they will meet the new fields and the attestation, and put the answer in your records.

The thread this month

The thread is verification. The new rule gives fiduciaries a right to check what their PBM and its affiliated advisers are paid, and claims-payment disputes are reaching the courts. The question for your committee is whether it can show that it looked.

Over the rolling three months to the end of October, the tracker logged 24 milestones, 4 of them critical. The same measure at the October issue, recalculated, was 17 milestones and 2 critical. The Pressure Index now reads 95 out of 100 (EXTREME). The activity counts show the pace more clearly than the index does, and the Pressure Index correction below explains why we recalculated October.

A September ruling we missed: no private right to enforce IDR awards in the Second Circuit

On September 17, 2026, the Second Circuit held in East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna (No. 25-2204) that the No Surprises Act gives out-of-network providers no private right of action, express or implied, to sue to enforce independent dispute resolution (IDR) awards. The provider had won more than $3 million in awards against Cigna. The court affirmed the dismissal of its suit. It reasoned from the statute's text and from an enforcement scheme that assigns enforcement to regulators: the Department of Labor, which may sue private employer-sponsored group health plans under ERISA, the Treasury, HHS, and the states. A law-firm alert reports that the Fifth Circuit reached the same conclusion. We missed this decision in earlier editions, and the tracker now carries it.

What to do: The ruling limits who can sue your plan or its administrator over an unpaid award, but the awards remain binding and regulators can enforce them. Ask your TPA or carrier in writing who pays IDR awards and from what source, whether any fee is charged on IDR outcomes, how unpaid awards are tracked, and how your committee is told about them.

Corrections to earlier editions

Express Scripts and the FTC. Our September 2026 digest said the FTC consent order with Express Scripts "became final in February 2026," and that only one of the three PBMs the FTC pursued had reached a final order. That was wrong as written. The FTC announced the Express Scripts settlement on February 4, 2026, and the Federal Register published it on February 12 (91 Fed. Reg. 6640) as a proposed consent agreement open for public comment through March 16. The FTC case page for the matter, last updated July 14, 2026, lists the Express Scripts decision and order as proposed, and we did not find a final-order entry. We have not been able to confirm from the FTC when, or whether, the order was made final, so we now describe it as a settlement announced in February. Please do not rely on our earlier statement that any of the three orders is final. We have corrected the same wording in the tracker.

The October Pressure Index. The October tracker displayed a Pressure Index of 86 and a three-month change of +11 points, built on 8 milestones, 1 of them critical. Those inputs left out 16 of the tracker's 59 milestones. Recalculated with the same formula on all 59, October reads 95, with 17 milestones and 2 critical. The November tracker uses the corrected inputs. The move from 86 to 95 is a correction to October's inputs, not a one-month rise in risk.

Virginia SB 669. The tracker described Virginia's PBM law, signed March 31, 2026, as taking effect on staggered dates through July 1, 2027. The enrolled act amends Va. Code §§ 38.2-3467 and 38.2-3470 with a single effective date, July 1, 2027, and separately directs the State Corporation Commission to report on PBM steering of covered individuals to affiliated pharmacies by December 1, 2027. We read the enrolled text and the Code of Virginia's 2026 updates page, and we corrected the tracker.

Where does your plan stand?

ClaimInformatics™ offers a complimentary ASO agreement and SPD analysis to find hidden fiduciary risks in your self-funded plan contracts before renewal. Request a complimentary ASO analysis, or email hello@claiminformatics.com. To see how ClaimInformatics supports fiduciary oversight, explore FOCUS™.

Related resources

FAQs Block

What did the Labor Department's final PBM fee disclosure rule do?

The Department released a final rule on October 29, 2026, that requires PBMs, and brokerage and consulting providers affiliated with them, to disclose their compensation to the fiduciaries of large self-insured group health plans. The Federal Register published it on November 2, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 69092). It is effective January 4, 2027 and applies to plan years beginning on or after July 1, 2027.

Who sued UnitedHealth Group in October 2026?

Aramark, Kraft Heinz, Whirlpool, W.W. Grainger, Ralph Lauren, and Sterling Jewelers, with their benefit committees and plans, filed suit on October 20, 2026, in the Eastern District of Texas. The docket lists the complaint as filed under seal and carries a redacted version that describes the allegations, and UnitedHealthcare told the press that it strongly disagrees and intends to vigorously defend against them.

What is Kreutzmann v. Cigna?

It is a putative class action filed October 12, 2026, in the Southern District of California by a participant in a self-funded plan. It alleges that Cigna, as administrator, uses a shared-savings arrangement that suppresses reimbursement of out-of-network ground ambulance claims while earning fees tied to the gap between the billed and paid amounts. These are allegations, and the docket entries available to us, which run through October 22, show no answer yet.

What changes on November 1 and November 13 for No Surprises Act disputes?

CMS says that from November 1 the Federal IDR Gateway initiation form enforces a 50-line-item cap on batched disputes and a 30-business-day cooling-off period for batched disputes whose open negotiation period begins on or after that date. The Gateway web forms go live on November 13, and web forms outside the Gateway stop being available after January 15, 2027, except the resubmission form.

When does the Transparency in Coverage final rule take effect?

The rule published October 6, 2026, takes effect December 7, 2026. According to the Departments' FAQs, the amended file requirements apply from March 6, 2027, and the new files from September 6, 2027.

This content is provided for fiduciary decision-making purposes. It does not constitute legal advice. Plan fiduciaries should consult with qualified ERISA counsel before taking action on any recommendations.

Comments


bottom of page